Shelter Island Real Estate & Homes for Sale

LAST 4 3 2 1
Sort By:
Address not disclosed
Custom-built four-bedroom, three-bath home with private deeded beach rights, water views, spacious ...
$ 699,000
4 bd, 3 ba
MLS ID #2451032
10 Midway Rd
Shelter Island, Ny 11964

1.8-acre piece of property with Cottage-style, two-bedroom home. This property offers a 2.5-car hea...
$ 749,000
2 bd, 1 ba
MLS ID #2385598
Address not disclosed
Very unique home in the shape of a Conch shell. Set on 2.3 acres, the home looks out at a lovely po...
$ 674,900
2 bd, 2 ba
MLS ID #2168933
Address not disclosed
This Old Farm Was Recently Approved For 5 Homes And A Small, Park-Like Preserve. The Houses Have Al...
$ 627,900
3 bd, 2 ba
MLS ID #1093598
Address not disclosed
Magnificent location with 180 degree gorgeous bay views. This home is located at the point where Sh...
$ 3,500,000
4 bd, 3 / 1-½ ba
MLS ID #1089341
29 Osprey Rd
Shelter Island, Ny 11964

Secluded, private enclave of landmark Farmhouse on charming, private lane. Association beach and te...
$ 749,000
4 bd, 3 ba
MLS ID #1114595
Address not disclosed
Beautiful family home on scenic Menantic Creek. Private, spacious acre with lengthy dock to accomod...
$ 1,395,000
5 bd, 2 ba
MLS ID #2227991
Address not disclosed
This Old Farm Was Recently Approved For five Homes And A Small, Park-Like Preserve. The Houses Have...
$ 618,450
3 bd, 2 ba
MLS ID #1093600
Address not disclosed
Zen California chic Ranch with sunny, bright, airy rooms and meditation gardens. Master suite has g...
$ 895,000
3 bd, 2 ba
MLS ID #1092325
Address not disclosed
Renovated two bedroom, two bathroom Co-Op. Hardwood floors, fireplace, screen porch, water views de...
$ 425,000
2 bd, 2 ba
MLS ID #1059432
LAST 4 3 2 1
View the Map